Philadelphia Forced Into Overspending as Rob Manfred’s TV Gamble Backfires on Phillies’ Broadcasting Plans

The Philadelphia Phillies captivated an impressive average of 325,000 viewers per game, the highest in MLB yet. But for Philly fanatics, that loyalty might now mean reworking their budgets or even skipping a few games altogether. Because thanks to Rob Manfred’s media gamble, access has turned into a costly scavenger hunt.

Manfred himself said on a recent ESPN Sunday Night Baseball broadcast that things were “a little bit like a jigsaw puzzle” during the present talks. That puzzle forces fans to juggle Apple TV+ for Friday night games, Peacock for select broadcasts, Netflix for special events, and still keep their regular cable or streaming setup for NBC Sports Philadelphia. But he also mentioned that it will be “resolved in the next couple of weeks”. Until then, the viewing experience remains complicated and unpredictable.

Watching Phillies games could cost fans well over $600 a year as subscriptions stack up. Peacock Premium runs $10.99 a month ($132 annually), the NBC Sports Philadelphia add-on costs $24.95 a month ($299 annually), Apple TV+ adds another $12.99 a month ($156 annually), and ESPN Unlimited, if it secures MLB.TV, could reach $29.99 a month ($360 annually).  For fans who already pay for standard cable or another sports streaming service, these charges only pile on. Until a resolution emerges, fans are stuck juggling these expenses to keep up with their team.

Behind these costs are billion-dollar deals shaping MLB’s broadcast future. ESPN is close to finalizing a three-year, $1.65 billion deal, about $550 million annually, that would add MLB.TV to its platform, grant in-market rights for select teams, and secure a national game package across cable and streaming. NBCUniversal is negotiating a three-year deal worth nearly $600 million, roughly $200 million a year, to air Sunday Night Baseball and playoff games on both NBC and Peacock. Meanwhile, Netflix has locked in a yearly deal worth over $35 million for exclusive Home Run Derby coverage, marking a major step in MLB’s partnership with mainstream entertainment platforms.

Apple TV+ will keep Friday Night Baseball until 2028, ensuring that the subscription remains essential for fans. NBC’s Sunday night coverage will shift some games to Peacock during the NFL and NBA seasons, adding another paid layer. All these deals run through 2028, matching Fox and TBS timelines, which means MLB won’t revisit its overall broadcast model until 2029.

This estimate offers a realistic picture of the financial hardship, not to mention the subscription maze,  that fans could have to deal with because of the new media agreements that Rob Manfred might agree to. And that’s how exactly Manfred’s strategy backfires. Instead of turning record-high engagement, 325,000 viewers per game, into greater momentum, MLB risks eroding the very loyalty it depends on. At some point, fans may decide that chasing every stream simply isn’t worth the price of admission.